I have been fortunate to test out many bikes over the years both while working sales in a bike shop throughout college as well as my current role as a bike reviewer for Awesome MTB. From downhill to XC and everything in between, my testing has taken place on many different trail systems. From tech rock moves of the 50 Year Trail System in Tucson, Arizona to the epic downhill trails of Whistler British, Columbia, to the random amazing trail network I found in Omaha Nebraska, it has been one awesome ride!
Check out our "2025 Trail Bike Buyers Guide" here: https://youtu.be/MQqtSPTg1vw?si=YquBuSp--ZLTkD7a
One thing that I have taken away from my time testing bikes is that bikes are somewhat region specific, to an extent. Many times if you look at where a bike company is headquartered and what their backyard trails look like, you can get a better understanding of how a bike will ride.
Ibis bikes tend to be more poppy which makes sense given their back yard trails wind through forests with lots of roots and tight corners to play around on. Pivot Cycles has some of the most chunky terrain in their backyard of South Mountain, which makes their bikes higher stack heights, taller bottom bracket heights, and shorter chain stays make more sense. Yeti Cycles has many high speed Colorado single-track trails close to the office making how well their bikes perform at high speeds seem like a no brainer. Rocky Mountain is born and raised on the North Shore, which explains why their bikes do so well at traction over technical terrain. Same goes for Knolly bikes as well!
I could go on and on, but also want to put a disclaimer here. Does that mean if you don’t live in a bike company's region of the world that their bikes won’t work on your home trails? Not at all! Bikes can be ridden all over the country and will perform very well! But when picking out the bike for your trail network that you ride on a day to day basis, this is something that you should keep in mind!
As a bike reviewer, something that really helped me understand how to figure out what bike is for what rider is riding different trail networks all over the US. I have ridden amazing purpose built trails in Florida, awesome flow trails in Texas, steep techy trails in BC, jagged rock moves in Arizona, awkward rock move filled trails in the Adirondacks (New York), random trails in the middle of Kansas City, this wild trail network in Omaha (Nebraska), and so many more.
If I was in the market for a bike, one of the first things I would take into consideration is “what do my trails look like”? Are they chunky, awkward, and filled with slow speed tech? I would consider something like a Pivot, Rocky Mountain, Knolly, or Propain. Do you have a bunch of flow trails that need something more playful or more fun at high speeds? Ibis, Yeti, Specialized, etc are solid contenders here!
Now some brands do try and strike a balance. ARI bikes, Cannondale, Santa Cruz Bikes, and more recently Specialized with the Stumpjumper 15 have felt to me able to perform great on both techy terrain as well as trail systems that require a bit more of a playful feel as well as high speed stabilty. Do they sacrifice in some areas to achieve a more well rounded profile? Sometimes yes, and my job is to figure out all the areas a bike excels at and where it is sacrificing slightly to achieve that and explain it.
Another thing to note here, sometimes changing a few parts to a build can also adapt a bike better to your terrain. Bikes with a slightly more active suspension design come alive with carbon wheels and an air shock. Bikes that tend to prioritize efficiency get a bit of added traction with a wider rim profile and some lower tire pressure. Alloy wheels add compliance as do bars with flex built into them.
At the end of the day, there has never been a better time to be a mountain biker. There are so many amazing bikes on the market, and each one has a unique riding personality. Many of these brands are in it for the passion as well and make bikes they want to ride themselves, so it makes sense why their bikes do so great in their own backyard.
How your backyard looks should to an extent factor into the purchase of your next bike, and that is what we are here to help with!
Happy Trails
-Mo Awesome
Awesome content and both the XC and Trail bike series were great! Hoping to see a "short travel" trail bike series in 2025. Anyway, given you have ridden where I live and primarily ride in the Adirondacks I am curious your take on a couple of bikes I should focus on. I currently have a short travel XC/Downcountry bike in the Revel Ranger and want to add a "bigger" bike. I am debating a 140F/130R or 150F/140R category bike. I have been thinking about the Yeti SB140, Trek Fuel EX or Evil Offering on the bigger side or maybe the new Ibis Ripley V5 for the 140/130 category. I had a Santa Cruz Hightower V3, great bike, but for me…